Peer Review Process

The peer review process is designed to ensure the rigorous selection of manuscripts submitted for publication.

The manuscript submitted by the author is reviewed within two weeks for compliance with the journal's scope and technical requirements, including an analysis for signs of plagiarism. Materials that do not meet these requirements are rejected. The Editorial Board informs the author(s) via a response letter regarding the receipt of the article and whether it has been sent for peer review or rejected.

All scientific articles published in the journal undergo a double-blind peer review process conducted by experts in the relevant field. The Editorial Board strives to prevent any conflicts of interest between authors and reviewers. Reviewers treat the submitted manuscripts as the intellectual property of the authors and as confidential material, guaranteeing the author's right to non-disclosure of the content until publication.

The Editorial Board pays special attention to preventing conflicts of interest between authors and reviewers.

Using reports from automated plagiarism detection systems (StrikePlagiarism) provided alongside the anonymized manuscript and review form, the reviewer identifies the absence of unlawful misappropriation, confirms the originality of the research, and ensures that all ideas, results, and texts of other authors are properly cited.

The reviewer evaluates the scientific and theoretical level of the article, its relevance and practical significance, the completeness of the research, the logic of the arguments, the reliability of the results, and the validity of the conclusions. Based on this assessment, the reviewer decides whether the manuscript meets the established requirements, requires revision, can be accepted for publication, or should be rejected.

If the reviewer recommends changes, the Editorial Board returns the manuscript to the author for revision, after which it is reconsidered. The author is given no more than one week from the date of notification to incorporate changes into the manuscript. The author may disagree with the reviewer's recommendations and has the right to submit reasoned objections. The final decision on further consideration of the material is made by the Editor-in-Chief.

In the event of a negative assessment, the author has the right to review the detailed justification provided by the reviewer and, if objective grounds exist, to appeal the decision. A reassessment by another expert (arbitration review) is conducted if the author can prove the existence of a factual error or bias on the part of the reviewer.

The Editorial Board does not engage in substantive discussions of the manuscript with the author. The final decision on publication is made by the Editorial Board of the journal.

To avoid potential conflicts of interest, articles submitted by members of the Editorial Board are considered without the participation of the respective member in the decision-making process. When considering material submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, the process is led by the Deputy Editor or, if necessary, an invited editor. When reviewing material submitted by a member of the Editorial Board, a reviewer is appointed from among colleagues who have not been co-authors of publications or joint grant recipients with the author within the last three years.

The total duration of the review process (initial screening – independent expert evaluation – revision if necessary – final decision) is determined individually based on the volume and specifics of the submitted material; however, the Editorial Board aims for this process not to exceed two months.

If an article is returned for technical revision, the date of submission after revision is considered the submission date. Acceptance Date — the date the manuscript is approved after peer review. Publication Date — the date the electronic version of the article is published on the journal's website and assigned a DOI.

Retraction Policy

Despite the rigorous review of all submitted materials, the Editorial Board recognizes the possibility of an objective need to revise the status of an article after its publication. Guided by the principles and requirements set forth on the COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) website, the Editorial Board may initiate a retraction procedure.

The purpose of a retraction is to correct published information and ensure the integrity of scientific publications. The initiative for retraction may come from the authors, the journal's editorial board, the institution where the authors work, or representatives of the academic community.

The decision to officially retract a published scientific article is made by the Editorial Board in cases of violations of publishing ethics and/or other significant deficiencies, including:

  • Errors, plagiarism, or unlawful misappropriation of text, ideas, data, or research results;
  • Lack of proper citations to primary sources;
  • Duplicate publication of the same article in another journal without proper justification;
  • Inclusion of authors who did not make a significant scientific contribution, or exclusion of those who did;
  • Identification of unethical peer review methods;
  • Conflicts of interest that could have influenced or did influence the research results, etc.

The Editorial Board is obliged to notify the author of the retraction and provide a justification for the decision; indexing databases are also notified of the retraction.

If a decision is made to retract an article, it is marked as "retracted" in all versions of the journal. A "Retraction Notice" is published on the website, containing bibliographic data, a link to the original article, a detailed justification for the retraction, and the effective date of the decision. The retracted article remains in the journal's archive with the corresponding watermark/mark.

Complaints Procedure Regarding Ethical Violations

This procedure defines the rules for filing, considering, and making decisions on complaints concerning publication ethics, academic integrity, and conflicts of interest. The core principles of the review are objectivity, confidentiality, impartiality, and mandatory feedback.

Complaints must be submitted in writing (electronically) to the official address of the editorial office, addressed to the Editor-in-Chief. The complaint must include the full name and contact details of the complainant (anonymous complaints are considered only if compelling evidence is provided), as well as a link to the specific material (article) with a detailed description of the alleged violation and supporting evidence (comparative tables, links to primary sources, etc.).

The complaint review process includes:

  1. Preliminary screening – within 10 working days, the Editor-in-Chief or Executive Secretary assesses the validity of the complaint;
  2. Formation of an Ethics Committee – if the complaint is deemed valid, a temporary committee (5 members) is formed, which may include members of the Editorial Board and independent experts;
  3. Communication with authors – the Editorial Board informs the authors of the complaint and provides them with the opportunity to present explanations within 10 working days;
  4. Ethics Committee Decision – based on a thorough examination of all arguments, the committee issues one of the following conclusions: "no violation," "minor violation (requiring correction)," or "serious violation."

Depending on the severity of the violation, the editorial decision may include: rejection of the manuscript (if not yet published); publication of official corrections (as a separate document with its own DOI and link to the original article); retraction of the article with an official notice on the website and in the next issue; or notification of the leadership of the researcher's institution.

The editorial decision may be appealed within 10 days from the date of receipt of the notification of the review results.