Copyright notice:

Copyright and licensing statement

Privacy statement

1. The name, email address, phone number, and other personal data entered in the manuscript submission form on the journal’s website are directly provided to anyone for contacting the author.

2. A double-blind review process is not available for authors and is carried out jointly with the editor. The names of the reviewers are unknown to the author, and the reviewers do not know the identity of the author. The parties cannot correspond with each other.

3. All correspondence between editors/authors/reviewers is stored in the journal’s system and may be used in court if necessary.

By submitting an article, the author is provided information regarding the journal’s Privacy Policy, Copyright and Licensing Statement, Publication Ethics, and Misconduct Policy.

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers must provide timely, written, qualified, and impartial feedback on the article and evaluate its scientific aspects and significance.

Reviewers evaluate the article for its relevance to the journal's focus, the practicality of the research topic and methods used, the novelty and scientific significance of the information in the article, the style of presentation, and scientific technicality.

Reviewers are required to report to the editor any reasonable suspicion or information about possible ethical violations by authors. Reviewers are required to identify relevant published work that has not been cited by the authors and to inform the editor of any significant similarities between the article under review and any article published or being considered for publication in another journal, if they are aware of such similarities. Reviewers are also required to inform the editor of any simultaneous submission of the same article to another journal if they are aware of such circumstances.

Reviewers must ensure no conflict of interest with the research, authors, and/or funding sources. In case of any conflict, they must inform the editor immediately.

If a reviewer feels unqualified to evaluate the study presented in the manuscript or is unable to review it promptly, they must notify the editor without delay.

The review process must be objective. Personal criticism of the author is not allowed. Reviewers must clearly express their views and support them with evidence.

All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers cannot use unpublished materials from the manuscripts without written permission from the authors. Information and ideas obtained from the manuscripts must be kept confidential and not used for personal purposes.

If an author disagrees with the conclusion of the reviewer and/or the editor, or with specific comments, they may appeal the decision. To do this, the author must:

• revise the manuscript in accordance with the reviewers’ and editors’ justified comments;
• clearly present their position on the issue under consideration.

Editors facilitate the resubmission of manuscripts that could potentially be accepted but were rejected due to the need for substantial revisions or additional data collection, and they are willing to explain in detail what needs to be corrected in the manuscript for it to be accepted for publication.